Montello, WI Lake Property For Sale (12 Real Estate Listings)

Sort by:
Active
201 Main Street, Montello

$1,750,000 Rendezvous Paddle&Sports

↓ $250,000

201 Main Street, Montello

6 Acres 5,700 SqFt Commercial MLS® # 1997172

Rendezvous Paddle & Sports x Montello Brewing Company. Discover a unique investment opportunity with this exceptional restaurant featuring a fully operational craft brewery, perfect for beer...

National Land Realty LLCRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
W3021 County Road C, Montello

$899,000 Fox Lake

↓ $76,000

W3021 County Road C, Montello

27 Acres Land MLS® # 2004977

A Montello Hidden Treasure...this is a must see to appreciate. Let's start with the 9000 sq foot building with 4 overhead doors, insulated, concrete floors, heated, plumbed with a bathroom a...

Cotter Realty LLCRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
L1 County Road C, Montello

$549,990 Fox Lake

↓ $100,010

L1 County Road C, Montello

26 Acres Land MLS® # 2004978

A hidden treasure....26+ acres that open up to a slice of camping heaven. RV sites with electric are already present, garage for added storage and the best of all 1900+ feet of winding front...

Cotter Realty LLCRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Pending
New
W2632 Fox Lane, Montello

$400,000 Fox Lake

W2632 Fox Lane, Montello

3 Beds 3 Baths 0 Acres 3,000 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2007274

Seller accepted offer from one party listing. VR $375,000-$400,000. Home has potential. Tucked away in the back of Rivers Bend Resort you will find this single family home backing to the Fox...

House To Home NowRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
315 Underwood Avenue, Montello

$399,900 Lake Montello

↓ $15,100

315 Underwood Avenue, Montello

3 Beds 2.5 Baths 0 Acres 1,577 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2005334

Turnkey and fully remodeled lakefront home on Lake Montello with stunning water views and a private pier. This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home features a spacious main floor primary suite, convenie...

Epique RealtyRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
286 Lake Avenue, MONTELLO

$258,000 Buffalo Lake

↓ $17,000

286 Lake Avenue, MONTELLO

4 Beds 1.5 Baths 0 Acres 1,965 SqFt Single Family City of Montello MLS® # 50312557

Located on the shores of Buffalo Lake, this 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home built in the early 1900s is the perfect opportunity for someone to bring their vision and modern touches to a piece of hi...

Keller Williams Green BayRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
14 Sunset Drive, Montello

$250,000 Buffalo Lake

↓ $25,000

14 Sunset Drive, Montello

2 Beds 1 Bath 0 Acres 1,224 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2008955

100 feet of frontage on Buffalo Lake & located right in the heart of Montello! Come and take a look at this 2 bedroom ranch style home with an up north feel! Open floor plan - large entryway...

Realty SolutionsRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
New
N3005 Lakeview Drive, MONTELLO

$240,000 Buffalo Lake

↓ $10,000

N3005 Lakeview Drive, MONTELLO

1 Bed 1 Bath 0 Acres 800 SqFt Single Family Town of Packwaukee MLS® # 50303148

Lakefront Living at Its Best! Your perfect escape awaits on Buffalo Lake in the Town of Packwaukee. Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a year-round home, this newly remodeled pr...

Adashun Jones, Inc.Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
213 Kilby Lake Road, Montello

$210,000 Kilby

213 Kilby Lake Road, Montello

1 Acres Land MLS® # 2003876

Beautiful level lot offering 150' of water frontage on Kilby Lake. Great Sunset views. Platform wooden patio for you to enjoy and watch the sunsets! Kilby Lake is a no wake lake approxi...

First Weber IncRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
.57 Ac Water Street, Montello

$69,900 Buffalo Lake

↑ $5,000

.57 Ac Water Street, Montello

1 Acres Land MLS® # 1855894

Montello City Lot with about 104 feet of Buffalo Lake water frontage! Hilltop views of lake. All wooded. A steal!...

Whitemarsh Properties LLCRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Pending
County Road C 20, MONTELLO

$59,900 Buffalo Lake

County Road C 20, MONTELLO

0 Acres Land Town of Montello MLS® # 50314258

Buffalo Lake. Approx 77 ft of water frontage offers world-class fishing, walleye, bass, northern, blue gill, crappie. Full rec boating lake. Or enjoy a relaxing pontoon ride. Excellent kayak...

Keller Williams Fox CitiesRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Active
Lot 26 Lalor Lane, Montello

$50,000 Fox Lake

↓ $4,000

Lot 26 Lalor Lane, Montello

1 Acres Land MLS® # 2002603

Just south of Montello sits this 0.88 acre lot in a quiet newer subdivision. 100ft of private water frontage on the Fox River - hop in a boat and make your way down to Lake Puckaway! Loads o...

Realty SolutionsRegional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota Logo

Montello, WI Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $324K
Lowest Price $9.9K
Highest Price $1.8M
Total Listings 50
Avg. Days On Market 257
Avg. Price/SQFT $185

Property Types (active listings)


As of October 18, 2025 there are 12 active Montello, WI lake property listings for sale with an average listing price of $428,058. The highest-priced waterfront listing is $1,750,000, while the lowest priced waterfront listing can be purchased for $50,000. Montello, WI lakeshore listings have an average price of $360 per square foot, based on listings with an average of 2.6 bedrooms, 1.8 bathrooms, and 1,189 square feet of living space.

Contact Us

Provide a valid email address.
Newsletter consent