Montello, WI Lake Property For Sale (14 Real Estate Listings)

Sort by:

$1,750,000 Rendezvous Paddle&Sports

201 Main Street, Montello

6 Acres 5,700 SqFt Commercial MLS® # 1997172

Rendezvous Paddle & Sports x Montello Brewing Company. Discover a unique investment opportunity with this exceptional restaurant featuring a fully operational craft brewery, perfect for beer...

National Land Realty LLC

$899,000 Fox Lake

W3021 County Road C, Montello

27 Acres Land MLS® # 2004977

A true Montello hidden treasureâthis property is one you must see to fully appreciate. The impressive 9,000 sq. ft. building is designed for versatility, featuring four overhead doors, full ...

Cotter Realty LLC

$549,990 Fox Lake

L1 County Road C, Montello

26 Acres Land MLS® # 2004978

A rare findâthis 26+ acre property opens up to a private retreat ideal for camping, recreation, and relaxation. Multiple RV sites with electric service are already in place, complemented by ...

Cotter Realty LLC

$445,000 Lake Montello

272 Carriage Road, Montello

3 Beds 2 Baths 0 Acres 2,200 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2025440

Montello Lake home with amazing waterfront views. Large family home with over 2,000 sq ft consisting of 3 bedrooms, 2 baths w/tubs & separate showers and a spacious open-concept living, dini...

First Weber Inc

$415,000 Fox River

W2632 Fox Ln, Montello

3 Beds 3 Baths 0 Acres 3,000 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 1969704

Fox River waterfront 2002 ranch home with abundant wildlife and stunning views! Bright open floor plan with skylights and multiple patio doors overlooking the river. Enjoy fishing, boating, ...

Real Broker LLC

$359,900 Lake Montello

117 S Main Street, Montello

3 Beds 1.5 Baths 0 Acres 1,700 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2031916

Enjoy waterfront living in the heart of Montello! This 2-story home offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a 2-car garage and approximately 200 feet of frontage on the Montello River with beautiful v...

United Country Midwest Lifesty

$355,000 Buffalo Lake

↓ $15,000

W4043 County Rd C Road, Montello

2 Beds 1.5 Baths 0 Acres 1,443 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2026777

Beautifully updated, move-in ready 2BR, 1.5BA accessible ranch home on Buffalo Lake offering 1,443 sq. ft. of single-story waterfront living! The bright, sun-drenched kitchen features modern...

Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Special Properties

$350,000 Buffalo Lake

↓ $10,000

280 Lake Avenue, Montello

4 Beds 2 Baths 0 Acres 2,468 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2029792

Experience the best of Wisconsin lake living in this beautifully updated 4 bedroom, 2 bath waterfront home on the shores of Buffalo Lake in Montello, Wisconsin. With 60 feet of frontage on a...

Real Broker LLC

$300,000 Buffalo Lake

3730 W Oak Street, Montello

3 Beds 2 Baths 1 Acres 1,440 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2031451

Looking for a lake property, a year round residence or a potential investment property, look no further. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home on Buffalo lake is available to make some memories. Mai...

Showen Properties

$275,000 Fox Lake

↓ $10,000

129 E Water Street, Montello

3 Beds 2 Baths 0 Acres 907 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2019557

Welcome to your Northwoods-inspired escape in Montello—where cozy cabin charm meets life on the water. Inside, you’ll love the vaulted ceilings, warm wood floors, and stunning stone wood-bur...

Compass Real Estate Wisconsin

New

$99,900 Williams Lake

↓ $20,000

Fox Road, MONTELLO

1 Acres Land MLS® # 50324205

Build your dream getaway here! Scenic lake lot on Packers Bay of Williams Lake. Level lot with 153ft of frontage. Fully recreational lake with swimming, fishing and water skiing. Build site ...

EXP Realty LLC

$99,000 Deeded Access

↓ $30,000

W1718 Fur Dr, Montello

2 Beds 1 Bath 0 Acres 800 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 1977068

Well maintained 2 bedroom cottage with access to lake puckaway where the sunsets never disappoint. Newer furnace and central A/C. New flooring and newer roof. Open concept! Deeded access...

KWS Realty (Kathy Wolf and Sons Realty)

$69,900 Buffalo Lake

.57 Ac Water Street, Montello

1 Acres Land MLS® # 1855894

Montello City Lot with about 104 feet of Buffalo Lake water frontage! Hilltop views of lake. All wooded. A steal!...

Whitemarsh Properties LLC

$34,900 Puckaway Lake

↓ $5,000

#9 - W2630 Fox Lane, Montello

1 Bed 1 Bath 1,280 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 2027329

Completely remodeled within the last two years, this charming 1997 Franklin home is move-in ready and located in the desirable Sunrise Resort Campground. Recent updates include a new roof, s...

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Water City Realty

Montello, WI Real Estate Statistics

Average Price	$343K
Lowest Price	$29.9K
Highest Price	$1.8M
Total Listings	33
Avg. Days On Market	473
Avg. Price/SQFT	$159

Property Types (active listings)

As of September 20, 2026 there are 14 active Montello, WI lake property listings for sale with an average listing price of $. The highest-priced waterfront listing is $, while the lowest priced waterfront listing can be purchased for $. Montello, WI lakeshore listings have an average price of $ per square foot, based on listings with an average of bedrooms, bathrooms, and square feet of living space.